The Country Life Ain't for Everyone — Here's Who Went Home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'

Jennifer Tisdale - Author
By

May 2 2024, Published 10:00 p.m. ET

Farmer Wants a WIfe's Season 2 men
Source: Michael Becker/Fox

Spoiler alert: This article contains major spoilers for Season 2 of Farmer Wants a Wife.

Fox's reality show Farmer Wants a Wife is a slightly different take on The Bachelor with hints of Yellowstone thrown into the mix. Four self-described farmers are hoping to find love in a big city way. Instead of looking inward to find out what they might be doing wrong, these cowboys are looking outward to women who are usually geographically unattainable.

Article continues below advertisement

That's right, women are flocking to the country from the urban jungles of America to find a slower life and a sweeter husband in Farmer Wants a Wife. Naturally, some of the contestants won't vibe with our rugged rodeo chaps. Here's who went home on Farmer Wants a Wife (hopefully, the women were able to hail a cab, not a cow!)

Week 1: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

The men of Farmer Wants a Wife Season 2
Source: Mark Hill/Fox

In Season 2, Episode 1, the men meet a bevy of women here to saddle their hearts. But at the end of the premiere, they have to narrow their respective rosters down to just five ladies.

Ty sends home both Allison Hozeska and Ashleigh Guich. However, his third eliminated contestant Christine Cosentino goes home on her own, citing a stressful and overwhelming environment.

Article continues below advertisement

Of the ladies here for Nathan, Destiny Freeman, Kiara Jones, and Lexie Jonier head home.

Nathan sends Emily Pellistri, Kandice Peterson, and Rachel Clanton home on night one.

And Brandon says goodbye to Britt Klocko, Madison Anderson, and Tayana Harrison.

Article continues below advertisement

Week 2: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

Erin from Season 2 of Farmer Wants a Wife
Source: Michael Becker/Fox

In Week 2 of Farmer Wants a Wife Season 2, things get a little more intense. Although host Jennifer Nettles lets the farmers know they can send one woman home if they don't feel a spark, not everyone opts to end things with one of their ladies.

Article continues below advertisement

For Nathan, since Makenzie already went home on her own accord, he doesn't send anyone else packing. Mitchell and Brandon also decline to end things with any of their respective farm guests.

However, Ty does choose to send Erin Sossamon home, though there seems to be a mutual lack of a connection.

Article continues below advertisement

Week 3: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

Brittany from Season 2 of Farmer Wants a Wife
Source: Michael Becker/Fox

The third week of Farmer Wants a Wife Season 2 leaves off with a cliffhanger since not all of the guys make decisions about keeping or sending a lady packing. But during the group dates at the Clemson tailgating party, Brandon sits down with Brittany and admits to her that he doesn't feel a strong connection with her. She feels the same way, for the most part, and she leaves the party to head home for good.

Article continues below advertisement

Week 4: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

Rachel and Brooklyn from Season 2 of Farmer Wants a Wife
Source: Michael Becker/Fox

Nathan takes Rachel on a solo date to get closer to her after she has doubts about their connection. But in the end, they both know they're at different places in life, and Nathan sends Rachel home.

Brandon is the only other farmer who sends someone home. He breaks things off with Brooklyn because, to him, they are "not compatible."

Article continues below advertisement

Week 5: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

Reba and Annellyse from Season 2 of Farmer Wants a Wife
Source: Michael Becker/Fox

Week 5 is not good for Brandon on Farmer Wants a Wife. After weeks of Reba being sure she was the one for him, she opts to leave, because she doesn't believe they are soulmates and she doesn't want to stand in the way of Brandon finding someone. Later, Annellyse says she was "really craving that one-on-one time" when she was overlooked for the solo date. And, ultimately, she doesn't want to stand in the way of Brandon's other connections.

Article continues below advertisement

Week 6: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

Melanie and Amy from Season 2 of Farmer Wants a Wife
Source: Michael Becker/Fox

Both Mitchell and Ty narrow their ladies down to three each this week. After a lackluster date with Mitchell, Melanie decides it's best if she goes home, and he agrees. Elsewhere, Ty and Amy discuss kids again, and he admits that he doesn't know if he can see himself having more children. Since Amy wants a big family someday, they both agree that she should end her journey here.

Article continues below advertisement

Week 7: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

The Season 2 Farmer Wants a Wife guys with host Jennifer Nettles at a picnic table.
Source: Mark Hill/Fox

This week, we have a handful of threats from some of the ladies about leaving now that all four farmers brought someone back to their respective homes. But in the end, none of the women follow through. And in the seventh week, none of the Farmer Wants a Wife women go home.

Article continues below advertisement

Week 8: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

Kristin and Brooke from Season 2 of Farmer Wants a Wife.
Source: Michael Becker/Fox

In Episode 8, Kristin confides in Nathan, expressing doubts about her ability to further open up to him, even if she were to secure the next solo date. She acknowledges that they've unintentionally placed themselves in more of a "friend zone." Ultimately, she goes home.

Article continues below advertisement

Meanwhile, Brooke opts for a heart-to-heart with Ty, suggesting it might be time for him to send someone packing tonight. To her surprise, Ty decides that she's the one to go home. They recognize their communication issues, with Ty emphasizing that he "ultimately" cannot sustain a relationship lacking effective communication.

Article continues below advertisement

Week 9: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

Natalie and Ashley from Farmer Wants a Wife
Source: Fox

As the season comes to a close, tensions are high and the farmer have some touch decisions to make. Among those are letting a couple of ladies go, and in the Week 9 episode, two of the newbies leave the farm life behind.

Article continues below advertisement

Mitchell and Natalie chat about their former connection and, when Mitchell says, "For some reason, I don't feel the connection as much anymore, Natalie agrees and she heads home.

Article continues below advertisement

Elsewhere, Ashley opens up to Ty about needing to choose between her job as a nurse or continuing in the process. She reveals that she will lose her job if she doesn't go back home, and although they had a bit of a spark initially, Ty agrees that she should leave.

Article continues below advertisement

Week 10: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

Joy, Makenzie, and Kiana from Farmer Wants a Wife
Source: Michael Becker/Fox

Week 10's episode is the final one before the farmers each take two ladies back to the women's hometowns to meet their families. In other words, it's a pretty big deal. But for farmer Nathan, he doesn't have to make the decision of narrowing his ladies down since Makenzie tells him she has to head home to be with her father, whose health isn't doing great.

Article continues below advertisement

After Mitchell's date with Kiana, he meets with her to have a chat. He says he felt like their date was beautiful, but he doesn't know if it went the way he wanted it to. And after Mitchell tells Kiana, "I have a stronger connection with the other two girls," she heads home.

Article continues below advertisement

Joy decides to go home before Brandon can even share his decision with his final three ladies. She says that she has only ever brought one boyfriend home to meet her family and she was in love with him. She admits that she doesn't see her and Brandon getting to that point.

Article continues below advertisement

Week 11: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

Mitchell, Ty, Nathan, and Brandon in cowboy hats in a barn on Farmer Wants a Wife
Source: Mark Hill//Fox

Just when you thought the farmers were about to choose between each of their final two ladies, think again. The Week 11 episode marks the first of two episodes where the farmer travel to meet the families of their final two women. However, no decisions are made in this episode about who the men want to ride solo with into greener pastures.

Article continues below advertisement

Instead, each of the farmers — Mitchell, Ty, Nathan, and Brandon — spend time in one of their respective ladies' hometowns with their families. And Week 12 sees them do the same with their other final ladies.

Article continues below advertisement

Week 12: Who went home on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

Nathan, Ty, Mitchell, and Brandon walk together on the farm on Farmer Wants a Wife
Source: Mark Hill//Fox

Did you think Farmer Wants a Wife was going to make things easy and let us know who each farmer chooses after the first home visits? Nice try. Week 12 sees the farmers meet and spend time with the other of their respective final two ladies. And next week, all four men have a big decision to make.

Article continues below advertisement

Which women are still left on 'Farmer Wants a Wife'?

In case you've lost track, here's a rundown of the women who are still left on Farmer Wants a Wife — along with their corresponding farmer.

  • Brandon Rogers: Grace Girard, Emerson
  • Mitchell Kolinsky: Sydney Errera, Kait Smith
  • Nathan Smothers: Taylor Bedell, Allye Wright
  • Ty Ferrell: Melody Fernandez, Megan Lay
Article continues below advertisement

Who do you think each farmer will choose on Season 2 of Farmer Wants a Wife? We can't wait to watch and see!

New episodes of Farmer Wants a Wife air on Thursdays at 9 p.m. EST on Fox. Stream the next day on Hulu.

More from DreamDive

Latest Farmer Wants a Wife News and Updates

    © Copyright 2024 DreamDive. DreamDive is a registered trademark. All Rights Reserved. People may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.